Cultural heritage · 2000

Assisi, the Basilica of San Francesco and Other Franciscan Sites

What UNESCO protects

Assisi is inscribed on the World Heritage List under five criteria, a high number. The first recognizes a group of masterpieces of human creative genius, such as the Basilica of San Francesco. The second stresses that the exchange of artistic and spiritual messages of the Franciscan Order contributed to the development of art and architecture. The third describes it as a unique example of the continuity of a sanctuary city, from its Umbro-Roman origins to the present day.

The fourth considers the Basilica an outstanding example of an architectural complex. The sixth links Assisi, birthplace of the Franciscan Order, to a universal message of peace and tolerance. According to other sources consulted the inscription dates from 2000, whereas the UNESCO source consulted does not give the year.

The site

. Cultural · Inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 2000.

Places within the UNESCO perimeter

  • Basilica of Santa Maria degli Angeli and Palace of the Captains of the Pardon
  • Town of Assisi, San Damiano, Eremo delle Carceri, Shrine of Rivotorto and historic landscape

Criteria for inscription

  • (i) A masterpiece of human creative genius
  • (ii) Exchange of ideas and techniques that influenced architecture, the arts, town planning or landscape
  • (iii) An exceptional testimony to a cultural tradition or to a civilisation
  • (iv) An outstanding example of architecture, technology or landscape illustrating a significant stage in history
  • (vi) Directly or tangibly associated with events, living traditions, ideas or works of outstanding universal significance
Number on the List
990

Where it is

UNESCO places the property in Umbria, on the slopes of Colle Asio, at the foot of Monte Subasio. The medieval historic centre stands on the foundations of the terraced Roman city. It includes the Basilica of San Francesco, the Basilica of Santa Chiara and the Rocca Maggiore.

Outside the walls are the Eremo delle Carceri, the shrines of San Damiano and Rivotorto and the Basilica of Santa Maria degli Angeli, on the plain. These are places spread over a wide territory, and this explains why a complete visit requires more than one route.

Two levels and a hill

The Basilica of San Francesco is best understood by first observing its relationship with the slope. The complex looks out towards the valley and incorporates several levels in its construction. In the lower church, the gathered light and the structure of the vaults guide a slow visit. Going up to the upper church, the height, the luminosity and the relationship between walls and paintings change. It is worth comparing the two spaces on the same day, checking the movements between entrances and exits and respecting the hours of worship.

Area and buffer zone

UNESCO gives 145.6 square kilometres for the property and 40.87 for the buffer zone. Another source, for the municipal territory, cites 145.6 square kilometres of protected area and 48.07 of buffer zone. The area of the property coincides, while the buffer zone differs.

An important aspect is that the protected area coincides with the entire municipal territory: not only the historic centre and the shrines, but also the landscape that surrounds them. Those who arrive in Assisi therefore walk inside a heritage property, not merely in front of a monument.

The story on the walls

In the upper basilica the Franciscan stories organize the space into successive scenes. The attribution of part of the cycle and the organization of the workshops are debated questions. One can observe directly the arrangement of the figures, the way the painted buildings construct a space and the gestures that allow the action to be followed. In the lower basilica other cycles offer a comparison between different painterly languages. In every space, taking a few episodes as a reference makes it easier to find one’s bearings in the density of the images.

Cimabue, Giotto and the attributions

Another source recalls, in the captions, a portrait of Saint Francis attributed to Cimabue and a fresco of Saint Clare attributed to Giotto. The guide already on the page notes that the attribution of part of the cycle in the upper basilica is a debated question.

It is a useful way of looking: attributions change with scholarship, but the narrative form and the distribution of the scenes remain visible to the viewer. The painter’s name matters less than observation.

Piazza del Comune and Santa Chiara

Going up from the basilica towards the centre, one crosses the medieval town. Piazza del Comune makes it possible to observe how the front of the Roman temple, reused in later periods, takes part in a layered civic space. At Santa Chiara the relationship between the building and the open space in front of the façade also matters. The route suits a leisurely half day. Going downhill the distances may seem short, while in the opposite direction the slope changes the time needed.

A city of stone and layers

On authenticity, UNESCO observes that the urban fabric reflects different periods and that the present form developed mainly between the end of the fifteenth and the eighteenth century. Since the mid-twentieth century very little has been built, and much of the construction is in limestone.

On integrity, the boundaries include all the elements that contribute to the outstanding universal value. The historical layering is preserved, and the landscape still has a strong visual impact. Those who look at the town from afar see a coherent whole of pale stone on the slope, and this effect is exactly what UNESCO calls the strong visual impact of the landscape. To take in the view it is best to stop at a panoramic point before entering, even for just a few minutes.

Santa Chiara, the Rocca and Piazza del Comune

According to other sources consulted, the body of Saint Clare was found in 1850. The Rocca Maggiore was destroyed in 1198 and rebuilt in 1356 by Cardinal Egidio Albornoz. The polygonal tower dates from 1458, and the bastion from 1535-1538. The Temple of Minerva faces the north side of Piazza del Comune.

These are dates that help to read the town as a sequence of phases: the Roman city, the medieval reconstructions, the interventions of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. The Cathedral of San Rufino is the cathedral where, according to a caption from the same source, Frederick II was baptized.

San Damiano and the Porziuncola

San Damiano is reached by planning a detour outside the central core. The place helps to read another scale of the Franciscan landscape, made of paths and secluded spaces. The Porziuncola is at Santa Maria degli Angeli, at the foot of the hill, inside the basilica that encloses it. The contrast of scale clarifies how a place of worship of minimal size can continue to direct the form and use of a larger building.

San Damiano, Santa Maria degli Angeli and the Hermitage

The Eremo delle Carceri stands on Monte Subasio and is included in the UNESCO site. San Damiano is a church where, according to other sources, during the Second World War Father Rufino Niccacci was guardian of the convent. Santa Maria degli Angeli is a hamlet with the basilica of the same name and the Porziuncola, and has the railway station of Assisi.

The detail about the station is practical: the railway station is in the hamlet on the plain, while the historic centre is on the hill, and to reach it one must allow for a transfer by local transport or a climb on foot, to be checked against the timetables. Those arriving by train must take this into account when planning the day.

How to look at the paintings in the two basilicas

In the upper basilica it is best to pause at the beginning of the nave. The series of Franciscan episodes occupies the lower band of the walls. The choice to set many scenes inside buildings, squares or recognizable landscapes guides the eye from one episode to the next. The name of Giotto is linked to this cycle, whose attribution continues to be debated. To follow the story it is enough to observe how the gestures and positions of the figures change with the setting.

In the lower basilica the low vaults create a different experience. The chapels and the crossings divide the visit into close-set stops. The tomb of Francis is in the crypt, reached from this level. Setting aside time for both churches makes it possible to grasp the relationship between the burial, the liturgy and the way the images tell the life of the saint.

The earthquake and the restorations

UNESCO recalls that, after the earthquake, the monuments were restored, including the partial collapses of the vaults of the Basilica of San Francesco. It does not give the date, and the text of another source consulted does not report the details of the quake. The guide therefore gives neither a date nor a number of victims.

This fact confirms that seismic risk is one of the main threats. UNESCO says that earthquakes have struck Assisi and Umbria since antiquity, and that restoration is part of the history of the property.

Protection

Protection operates at national, regional and local level. The main monuments are under the control of the competent offices of the Ministry. Since the 1950s the entire municipal territory has been protected for its natural and landscape value, and the Master Plan of 1972, regularly updated, identifies the protected areas.

For the visitor this means that the whole municipality has rules for the landscape. These are not restrictions on monuments alone but on the territory as well.

Management

A specific office of the Municipality manages the property. The management plan is reviewed and updated every five years, and the structural plan stands alongside it. The creation of an observatory to monitor natural and human factors is under study.

These are instruments that may change over time, and the guide reports them as they stand in the UNESCO description. For rules of access to sacred places, the religious custodians apply, with hours that depend on the celebrations.

Threats: earthquakes and tourism

The two threats indicated by UNESCO are earthquakes and tourism. Assisi is one of the main tourist sites in Italy and, according to UNESCO, the leading Christian pilgrimage destination after the Vatican.

This is felt on days of heavy attendance, when streets and basilicas are very full. It is better to choose less crowded times, such as early morning or evening, and to allow time for the quieter places, such as the Hermitage.

Where the sources differ

The first point concerns the buffer zone: 40.87 square kilometres according to UNESCO, 48.07 according to another source. The guide cannot establish which figure is more up to date and refers to the official UNESCO data.

The second point concerns the dates. UNESCO does not give the year of inscription, while another source gives it as 2000. The text consulted does not confirm the 2021 extension, cited in the title of the page with the Franciscan sites, and for this reason the guide does not describe the added sites.

What the sources do not say

The sources consulted do not give the dates of the Basilica of San Francesco, do not describe the cycles of Giotto and give no information on the earthquake of 26 September 1997 or on the victims. The guide does not cite these data because it did not find them in the pages read.

For historical details it is best to consult the publications of the basilica’s website and museum guides.

A site in several parts

Assisi is a serial property: the Basilica of San Francesco and the other Franciscan places are to be read together.

A note on the sources

For Assisi the areas of the property and of the buffer zone differ between UNESCO and another source. The guide reports both and notes that the difference concerns mainly the buffer strip.

What to bear in mind when reading Assisi

The property is a series of places, and each place has its own history. The Basilica of San Francesco is the centre, but the sources also mention other Franciscan sites that are to be read as part of the same whole.

The history in stages

The medieval centre stands on Roman foundations, and the present form of the town developed between the end of the fifteenth and the eighteenth century. The Rocca Maggiore is destroyed in 1198 and rebuilt in 1356, with interventions in 1458 and in 1535-1538. In 1850 the body of Saint Clare is found.

Since the 1950s the municipal territory has been protected, and in 1972 the Master Plan identifies the protected areas. In 2000 the property enters the UNESCO List.

A day and a second outing

The basilica and the squares of the centre can fill a first visit. For San Damiano and Santa Maria degli Angeli a second outing is useful, or a day planned with a margin for the transfers. Check visiting hours and times of services with the custodians. Those with mobility needs should choose in advance the entrances and the direction of the walk, since the centre includes numerous slopes and stairs.

Key dates

  1. 1198Destruction of the Rocca Maggiore
  2. 1356Reconstruction of the Rocca by Albornoz
  3. 1850Discovery of the body of Saint Clare
  4. 1950sProtection of the entire municipal territory
  5. 1972Master Plan
  6. 2000Inscription on the UNESCO List

UNESCO source

Map of the site

© OpenStreetMap · ODbL

Sources and references