What UNESCO protects

The Fanjingshan is a mountain of the Wuling range, in Guizhou Province, in south-western China. UNESCO describes it as a natural property of 402.8 square kilometres, surrounded by a buffer zone of 372.4 square kilometres. The altitude runs from 500 to 2,570 metres and the highest peak is Mount Fenghuangshan, with a drop in height exceeding 2,000 metres.

The value of the property lies in its forest and the species it hosts. UNESCO presents it as an island of biodiversity in a heavily transformed landscape, and gives much space to numbers: over 3,700 plant species, more than 2,300 invertebrate species and 450 vertebrates. These are figures that describe the richness of the place better than any adjective.

The site

China. Natural · Inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 2018.

Criteria for inscription

  • (x) Important habitats for the conservation of biodiversity, including threatened species
Number on the List
1559

A single criterion, the tenth

The only criterion that UNESCO names in the justification is (x), that of in situ conservation of biodiversity. No other criteria appear in the text consulted.

It is a choice consistent with UNESCO’s data: the Fanjingshan is recognised not for the beauty of a single view nor for a geological phenomenon, but for the quantity of endemic and threatened species that live there. Two species, the Fanjingshan fir and the Guizhou snub-nosed monkey, are restricted to the property.

Where it is

According to other sources consulted the Fanjingshan lies in the Tongren area, in Guizhou, and is the highest peak of the Wuling, at 2,570 metres. The coordinates given are 27°53′44″ N and 108°40′48″ E, and the ground elevation starts from 480 metres.

UNESCO speaks of a Wuling range in south-west China and gives 500 metres as the minimum altitude. The difference between 480 and 500 metres is small, but the two sources do not coincide, and the guide reports both values with their origin.

The areas: property, buffer, reserve

UNESCO gives 402.8 square kilometres for the property and 372.4 for the buffer zone, which encloses it entirely. Another source reports the same figures, about 403 and 372 square kilometres, and adds a national nature reserve of 567 square kilometres.

The source does not explain how the three areas overlap: the sum of property and buffer, about 775 square kilometres, is larger than the reserve, and it is not clear whether the areas are measured by the same criteria. The guide does not try to reconcile the numbers and presents them separately.

Forests in altitude belts

UNESCO distinguishes two ecoregions: the Jian Nan subtropical evergreen forests, which cover 64 per cent of the property, and the Guizhou Plateau broadleaf and mixed forests, for the remaining 36 per cent.

Along the mountain the vegetation also changes. Below 1,300 metres evergreen broadleaves dominate. Between 1,300 and 2,200 metres there is a mixed wood of evergreens and deciduous trees. Above 2,200 metres deciduous broadleaves, conifers and shrubs are found. It is a succession typical of mountains with a great change in height, and explains why the property contains so many different environments in a relatively compact area.

Water and climate

According to UNESCO about 20 rivers and streams rise on the Fanjingshan and feed the Wujiang and Yuanjiang systems, which in turn flow into the Yangtze. The climate is monsoonal.

The text consulted reports no temperature or precipitation data. The guide limits itself to recalling the role of the mountain as a water reservoir for the downstream basins and refers those who want precise numbers to the local weather stations.

Flora

UNESCO counts 3,724 plant species, about 13 per cent of the Chinese flora, including 791 bryophytes, of which 74 are endemic to China, and 36 gymnosperms. Three beeches, Fagus longipetiolata, F. lucida and F. engleriana, dominate what the text calls the largest primary beech forest in the subtropical region.

Another source recalls that the Fanjingshan hosts the most extensive and continuous primary subtropical beech forest, without giving the extent. The detail matters: nearly all the subtropical beech forests of the world have been fragmented or transformed, and here a large and intact core remains.

Fauna

UNESCO lists 2,317 species of invertebrates and 450 of vertebrates. Among the endemics are 46 locally endemic plants, 1,010 plants endemic to China, 4 endemic vertebrates and 245 endemic invertebrates.

The emblematic species is the Guizhou snub-nosed monkey, which UNESCO says is restricted to the property. Another source calls it the “Guizhou golden monkey” and gives it the scientific name Rhinopithecus brelichi, without population figures. UNESCO also does not say how many individuals live in the property.

Threatened species

According to UNESCO, 64 plant species and 38 animal species are included on the IUCN Red List in the vulnerable, endangered or critically endangered categories. Among the examples are the Chinese giant salamander, critically endangered, the forest musk deer, endangered, Reeves’s pheasant and the Asiatic black bear, vulnerable.

These are data useful for understanding the role of the property: it does not protect a single charismatic species, but a set of species that are rare elsewhere. The text consulted does not describe the causes of the threats for each species.

The three components

The property is made up, according to UNESCO, of the Fanjingshan National Nature Reserve, the Yinjiang Yangxi Provincial Nature Reserve and a small area of non-commercial national forest.

UNESCO stresses that ecological connection between the components is fundamental to integrity. The nature reserve is also a UNESCO biosphere reserve, and the text recommends rationalising its zones with the boundaries of the property. Another source gives the nature reserve as established in 1978 and the biosphere reserve in 1986.

A Buddhist sacred mountain

This section draws on another source, because UNESCO, in the text consulted, does not mention it. The name Fanjingshan means “Pure Land of Brahma”, Fantian Jingtu, and the mountain is regarded as the place of enlightenment of the Maitreya Buddha. The source ranks it just below the four sacred mountains of Buddhism.

Buddhism is said to have been present there as early as the Tang period, and the Zangke road was built in 639. The period of greatest splendour is said to have been under the Ming and Qing dynasties, with temples of the Pure Land and Linji schools. In the sixteenth century a revolt damaged the temples, and the Wanli Emperor ordered them to be rebuilt.

Destruction and rebirth

According to other sources as well, the temples were destroyed by the unrest of the Republican era and by the Cultural Revolution, and recovery began in the 1980s. In 2010 the Fanjingshan Buddhist Cultural Park opened.

In the park’s Golden Hall stands a 5-metre statue containing 250 kilograms of gold, described as the largest gold statue of Maitreya in the world. The source, however, uses the phrase “it is said”, and the guide reports the claim as unverified.

Integrity

UNESCO states that the area was adequate at the time of inscription. It adds, however, that the ecological connection between the components is decisive and that protection requires coordination. It provides no monitoring data on the state of the populations.

For a non-specialist reader the lesson is that the boundaries of a natural property do not coincide with those of a park: a forest works if its parts remain connected, and for this reason UNESCO insists on a point that seems technical, namely the coherence between reserve and property.

Protection and management

All the land of the property is owned by the State. National and provincial laws apply, as well as village regulations. Management is divided among three bodies: the administration of the national reserve, that of the Yinjiang Yangxi provincial reserve and the forestry department.

UNESCO recalls that a single protection and management office was approved in August 2017, and that the Ministry of Natural Resources was established in March 2018. Plans exist for each component, except the non-commercial forest, as well as an ecotourism plan and a monkey conservation plan. Staff numbers are small but considered adequate at the time of inscription, with the support of the local police.

Tourism and villages

UNESCO points out that growing tourism must be managed in order to protect the outstanding universal value. A monitoring system for visitors, the environment, disasters and villages is under way.

For the villages inside the property and in the buffer zone there is a voluntary relocation programme with compensation, which according to the text must respect the principle of free, prior and informed consent. The text does not say how many people have been relocated or whether the programme has been completed.

Where the sources differ

The elevations are not the same: 500 metres for UNESCO, 480 for another source. The names of the summit also vary: the source speaks of “Red Cloud Golden Peak”, “New Golden Peak” and “Red Clouds Golden Summit”. The guide uses the highest peak of the Wuling range, at 2,570 metres, and does not choose a single name.

The areas do not reconcile either: 402.8 square kilometres of property plus 372.4 of buffer zone exceed the 567 square kilometres of reserve. And UNESCO speaks of a Guizhou snub-nosed monkey, while another source calls it a “golden monkey”: it is the same species with two common names.

What the sources do not say

The texts consulted do not state the year of inscription or the name of the State Party in the UNESCO description, and they give no population figures for the monkeys or other species. They do not report visitor numbers, opening hours, prices or recommended seasons.

Nor do they indicate specific threats such as poaching, logging or invasive species, or monitoring results or budget figures. For this reason the guide does not describe the current state of conservation, and refers readers to official Chinese sources for practical information.

How to read Fanjingshan

The property can be read on three levels. The first is the forest, with its succession of altitude bands. The second is the endemic fauna and flora, which explain criterion (x). The third is the sacred mountain, a level that UNESCO does not treat but that another source puts in the foreground.

Keeping these levels separate helps to avoid confusing the sources: one describes a natural property, the other a religious destination. Visitors find both in the same place, but protection concerns the former.

How to read the mountain’s numbers

For Fanjingshan the numbers change depending on the source, from the base elevation to the areas of the property, buffer zone and reserve. It is best to treat them as orders of magnitude and to cite each time who provided them.

The most solid figure is the highest peak of the Wuling massif, at 2,570 metres. Everything else, from the names of the summit to the areas, should be read with the caution suggested by the chapter on the differences between sources.

A note on the sources

For Fanjingshan the names of the summit and of the species change from one source to another. The guide uses the names given by the source it cites.

The history in stages

In 639 the Zangke road is built, which the sources link to the Buddhism of the mountain. In the Ming and Qing centuries the temples reach their period of greatest development. In 1978 the nature reserve is founded and in 1986 the biosphere reserve.

In 2010 the Buddhist Cultural Park opens, in August 2017 the single management office is approved and in July 2018, at the 42nd session of the Committee, Fanjingshan is inscribed on the World Heritage List under number 1559.

Key dates

  1. 639Zangke road
  2. 1978Nature reserve established
  3. 1986Biosphere reserve
  4. 2010Buddhist Cultural Park opens
  5. August 2017Single protection and management office approved
  6. July 2018Inscription on the UNESCO List

Map of the site

© OpenStreetMap · ODbL

Sources and references