Eight towns to be read together
The property comprises Caltagirone, Militello in Val di Catania, Catania, Modica, Noto, Palazzolo Acreide, Ragusa and Scicli. After the earthquake of 1693 great building sites opened, with differing timescales and decisions. The common thread is reconstruction, while the topography, the choice of sites and the use of the streets vary. A good itinerary compares at least two cases, for example the regularity of an axis in Noto and the way Ragusa adapts to heights and slopes.
The earthquake of 1693: the numbers
According to other sources consulted on the earthquake, the first strong shock was on 9 January 1693 at about 21:00, with its epicentre between Melilli and Sortino. On 11 January, at 9:00, there was a new shock, followed by another about an hour later, and at 13:30 the main event, of moment magnitude 7.3, the strongest recorded on Italian territory. It also caused a tsunami on the Ionian coasts and in the Strait of Messina. The depth of the hypocentre is estimated at about 20 kilometres.
The seismic swarm lasted about two years, with about 1,500 aftershocks. The structure that generated the earthquake probably lies at sea, between Catania and Syracuse: the most widely accepted hypothesis is the Hyblaean-Maltese system. The area with effects equal to or above degree XI on the Mercalli scale was about 5,600 square kilometres.
Victims and destroyed towns
The total victims are estimated by the source at about 60,000, and it also cites an estimate of 60,000 or 70,000. The Senators of Syracuse spoke of 93,000 dead, a different figure that the source reports as a historical estimate. More than 45 settlements were completely destroyed.
For individual towns, the text cites Catania with 16,000 dead out of about 20,000 inhabitants, Modica with 3,400 out of 18,200, Ragusa with about 5,000 out of 9,950, Lentini with 4,000 out of 10,000, Syracuse with about 4,000 out of 15,339 and Militello with about 3,000 out of almost 10,000. In Caltagirone the victims numbered more than 1,000. Of the 64 monasteries of the diocese of Syracuse only three remained standing.
Rebuilding in different ways
UNESCO describes different paths. Catania was rebuilt on its original site, Noto on a new site, Ragusa and Palazzolo Acreide placed new centres alongside the old ones, Scicli and Modica were moved to adjacent areas already partly urbanised, and Caltagirone was simply repaired. Reconstruction continued over the following decades, and another source places it in the early decades of the 18th century, with architectural and artistic solutions common to the whole Vallo.
The term Late Baroque is presented as the last flowering of European Baroque. For this reason the homogeneity of the buildings does not depend on a single architect, but on the fact that a large part of the region was rebuilt in the same period.
A geographical exception: Catania and Acireale
Another source recalls that Catania and Acireale, struck by the earthquake, belonged to the Val Demone and not to the Val di Noto in the administrative sense, but Catania is nevertheless included in the UNESCO list. The name of the property therefore indicates an area of reconstruction more than a historical boundary.
The same source recalls that other inscribed sites are found in the Vallo: the Roman Villa del Casale, in 1997, and Syracuse with the Necropolis of Pantalica, in 2005.
Noto and the monumental street
Along Corso Vittorio Emanuele the sequence of squares, palaces, churches and stairways lets even those visiting from outside read the differences between monuments. In front of the Cathedral it is useful to stop at different heights. From below the role of the stairway is grasped, while higher up the relationship with the neighbouring fronts becomes legible. In the side streets, balconies and sculpted brackets show how decoration works in the urban space. The colour of the stone changes with the light, so two passages at different times can bring out different details.
Whole centres and isolated monuments
The composition of the property is not uniform. For Caltagirone, Noto and Ragusa the entire historic centre is inscribed. For Catania and Scicli, specific urban areas are inscribed. For Militello in Val di Catania, Modica and Palazzolo Acreide, only isolated monuments are inscribed. This means that UNESCO protection does not cover every street of every town in the same way, and that the boundaries should be checked against the official UNESCO description when needed.
For visitors, the distinction helps in not expecting the same kind of experience everywhere: in the whole centres one walks inside the property, while in the others one looks for individual buildings.
Ragusa, Modica and Scicli
In Ragusa, the relationship between Ibla and the upper town is felt along the routes of ascent. In Modica, stairs and streets accompany a town spread across ravines and slopes. Scicli offers a comparison with streets and squares carved out of a space defined by the hills. In all three cases it is worth choosing a point from which to see the district as a whole and then entering the streets. The mediation between the shape of the terrain and the building is clearer than it appears in a visit oriented only to façades.
Integrity and authenticity
UNESCO considers that the property includes all the attributes necessary to express its value and that the centres keep their residential function and a living society of inhabitants. The buildings and the urban plans keep a remarkable stylistic homogeneity, and the urban plans are almost entirely preserved.
The property has, however, suffered further seismic events and long-term deterioration, and many buildings require restoration, consolidation and maintenance. This is useful for visitors to know: the beauty of the centres does not mean that everything is in perfect condition.
Catania, Caltagirone and the other centres
In Catania the reconstruction is read along the great axes and in the squares of the centre. Lava stone and light inserts bring out the composition of the buildings. Caltagirone makes it possible to add to the comparison the role of ceramics and of the urban change in level. Militello and Palazzolo Acreide deserve a stop of their own, choosing monuments and routes with attention to opening times. The UNESCO recognition concerns a defined set of components. To know whether a specific place falls within the property, consult the official text and map.
Other losses and a warning about the figures
The source on the earthquake also cites smaller centres. Occhiolà, the ancient Grammichele, lost 52 per cent of its 2,910 inhabitants. In Mineo the dead numbered 1,355 out of 6,723 inhabitants, in Licodia Eubea 258 victims were recorded out of about 4,000 inhabitants. For Acireale De Burigny’s estimate is about 2,000 dead, and in Vittoria, among the victims, the source recalls 40 children.
These are historical data, and the estimates of contemporaries differ. For this reason the guide presents them as figures reported by the source and not as certain numbers: for example the total of victims ranges between 60,000 and 93,000 according to those who calculated it.
Protection and responsibility
Most of the properties are privately owned, while others belong to the Church, the State and local authorities. The Provinces of Catania, Ragusa and Syracuse and the Municipalities of the eight towns are responsible. Among the main provisions UNESCO cites national laws 1089 and 1497 of 1939, 64 of 1974 and 431 of 1985, and regional laws 61 of 1981 and 15 of 1991.
In the central zones, 109 buildings are protected under Legislative Decree 42 of 2004. Every intervention must be approved in advance by the Superintendencies and the municipal administration. A management plan, drawn up at the time of inscription, is regularly revised.
Three answers to a difficult terrain
In Noto, the main street allows the relationship between palaces, churches and façades on the same axis to be read. Moving a few metres, one meets flights of steps and changes in level that multiply the viewpoints. In Ragusa Ibla the fabric proceeds on a more irregular slope and the cathedral of San Giorgio stands out particularly where the street widens. In Scicli the streets of the valley floor follow the relief and open out in front of individual monumental complexes.
The comparison can start from the balconies, the stairs and the way the façades show themselves in perspective. It is not necessary to put the three centres into the same day to grasp these differences. A walk that leaves the busiest street allows the backs of the buildings and the links with the inhabited districts to be observed more calmly. The reconstruction after the earthquake is thus read in the urban layouts as well as in the decoration.
Reconstruction as an urban project
From UNESCO it emerges that the reconstruction did not follow a single model. In Catania the choice was to rebuild where the city already stood, in Noto to change site, in Ragusa and Palazzolo Acreide to place a new centre alongside the old one, in Scicli and Modica to move to nearby areas already partly urbanised, in Caltagirone to repair. These are five different choices in the face of the same catastrophe.
The result is a set of towns with different forms but a common architectural language. UNESCO’s criterion (iv) relates precisely these two aspects: the geographical and chronological homogeneity arises from the event that forced rebuilding within a few decades.
Why criterion (v) matters
Criterion (v) is cited less than the others but explains the historical sense of the property: the region has had to live with earthquakes and eruptions of Etna, and the rebuilt towns show a settlement pattern and an urban form representative of this coexistence. In other words, the property preserves not only façades, but a way of inhabiting an unstable territory.
This reading helps in looking at the squares, the stairways and the churches as responses to a risk as well as expressions of style, and in understanding why UNESCO recalls artistic value and vulnerability together.
Permanent risks
UNESCO indicates as threats the permanent risk of earthquakes and eruptions of Etna, further seismic activity and long-term deterioration. For a property built after an earthquake this is a central theme: the 18th-century reconstruction is part of its value, but the centres remain in an active zone.
For visitors, the practical advice is to check the access status of churches and palaces, because restoration and consolidation work may limit entry.
How many centres in one trip
For two days, devote one visit to Noto and one to the Ragusa sector, choosing a second centre only if useful time remains. With more days one can pass through Catania and add a stop in the interior. In the programme, parking, climbs and entry hours matter. A stop reduced to a few minutes in front of the main church leaves little room to understand the relationship with the rebuilt town.
Key dates
- 1693Earthquake of 9 and 11 January
- 1695End of the seismic swarm (about two years)
- 18th c.Reconstruction of the centres
- 1997Roman Villa del Casale on the UNESCO List
- 2002Inscription of the Late Baroque towns
- 2005Syracuse and Pantalica on the UNESCO List
UNESCO source