The villas of the Mugello
The Villa of Cafaggiolo and that of Trebbio, today in the municipalities of Barberino di Mugello and Scarperia e San Piero, show well the persistence of fortified forms. At Cafaggiolo the fifteenth-century transformation linked to Cosimo the Elder and Michelozzo worked on an older nucleus. The residence had elements of defence and of control of the territory and was integrated with farms, roads and spaces intended for leisure. At Trebbio, the tower, the compact volume of the complex and the elevated position keep legible the relationship with the slope and the roads below.
The chronicles of the Florentine families’ stays explain another aspect of these places. Leaving the city meant being able to alternate government business, management of the estate, hunting and meetings with humanists. At Cafaggiolo the history of the Medici court is interwoven with that of Angelo Poliziano and with the education of the children of Lorenzo the Magnificent. This dimension invites a reading of the villas as places frequented repeatedly and according to the seasons, with practical needs different from those of urban dwellings.
On site, look above all for the relationship between the building and the roads along which it is approached. Up close the tower dominates the composition. Moving away, the spur of land, the roofs and the relationship with the plots count for more. Cafaggiolo and Trebbio have their own access arrangements, to be checked before building a day around the interiors. When the buildings can be seen only from the outside, choose points on public roads or paths and take account of private property. For a visit with times already fixed, it is more convenient to start from a venue with confirmed availability.
Careggi and the villa above Fiesole
Careggi and Fiesole are close to the city but occupy very different positions. Careggi preserves the memory of the intellectual habits of the Medici of the fifteenth century and of the circle of Marsilio Ficino. Its name recurs when speaking of the reading of Plato and of the network of relationships that united translators, scholars and patrons. The later history of the villa, with ownership, restorations and uses that changed over time, should be borne in mind before associating each visible room with a figure of Florentine culture.
The villa built at Fiesole for Giovanni de’ Medici instead faces a slope that opens the view towards Florence and the Arno valley. The terraces make use of the lie of the land and divide the greenery at different levels. At garden level, a small difference in height is enough to change the relationship between the building, the retaining wall and the distant city. The more measured elevations of this residence stand out when set beside the volumes of Trebbio, with its tower and fortified profile.
Whoever plans an architectural itinerary can use the comparison between the two villas to reconstruct the different ways in which the suburban residence approached the city. At Fiesole the public route requires coming to terms with a climb and with the outlook from the road. At Careggi the villa occupies an area that is today much more urbanised than its former setting. The regional catalogue and the operators’ pages make it possible to find one’s way among building works, openings and visiting days. The dates of special events are more likely to affect the programme than a simple distance in kilometres.
Castello and La Petraia, gardens to compare
The garden at Castello shows the programme of Cosimo I in a place where water and sculpture work to organise a route. Niccolò Tribolo worked on the layout of the garden and its articulation along the central axis. The Grotta degli Animali brings together figures of different species in an artificial setting that recalls rock and vegetation. It is useful to go and look for it after following the main avenues. The change of light and scale, from the flowerbeds and hedges to the small space of the grotto, is as much a part of the experience of the garden as the individual sculpted figures.
La Petraia is recognisable from afar by its tower. On the slope in front of the villa, terracing divides the hillside into different garden areas and opens the view over the plain. To this layout is added a history of transformations of the interiors, visible in the decoration of the courtyard and in the collections. The roofing of the courtyard and the arrangement of the rooms also testify to the Savoy period. To read the place, first observe the sequence of terraces, then look inside the building for the points at which a portion of the landscape comes into view again.
Castello and La Petraia are close enough to form a sensible itinerary, provided the opening times of the individual visitable parts are checked. At Castello, public access concerns the garden run by the state museum. At La Petraia, the route through the rooms of the villa may follow different arrangements from the one outside. Bring the plan of the complex to be visited second. It will then be possible to find again, with a precise reference, a staircase or an outlook that in the first garden had a different function. This pairing is particularly instructive when the sun makes it possible to distinguish the depth of the terraces clearly.
Boboli and the Poggio Imperiale
In Florence, Boboli spreads over the slope behind Palazzo Pitti. Work on the garden began in 1549 after Eleonora di Toledo’s purchase of the palace. Tribolo’s project was followed by the interventions of other artists, among them Bartolomeo Ammannati and Bernardo Buontalenti. Walking the axis above the palace, observe the relationship between the amphitheatre and the slope. Close up, the details of statues, fountains and niches emerge. Higher up, the view shows how these elements are distributed across the hill.
The Grotta del Buontalenti brings together architecture, images and surfaces that imitate natural formations. In other parts of the garden, the route along the avenues alternates sudden openings with stretches immersed in vegetation. The starting date says little about the form of Boboli today. Continual interventions have modified the visitable areas, the plant collections and the furnishings. It is worth leaving time for the side paths too and returning towards the palace by a different level, following the Uffizi map and taking account of the sectors that are open.
The Villa del Poggio Imperiale occupies another hill south of the city, reached by a long avenue. The residence preserves the memory of the women of the grand-ducal family, among them Maria Maddalena of Austria and Vittoria della Rovere. Its history includes substantial Lorraine-period works and its later use as an educational institution. The central block, the wings and the avenue offer starting points for reading how the role of the building and its relationship with Florence have changed. For the interiors, consult the operator’s calendar before pairing Poggio Imperiale and Boboli on the same day.
Poggio a Caiano and Artimino
Lorenzo the Magnificent entrusted the design of the villa at Poggio a Caiano to Giuliano da Sangallo. The layout places a large state room at the centre and uses the loggia to open the façade onto the territory. In the salone, the paintings executed by several artists and at different times show how long the building site remained a place of patronage. The cycle includes the famous episode of Vertumnus and Pomona painted by Pontormo. Arriving at the villa after observing its base and stairs, the size of the salone also becomes more legible from the inside.
On the top floor, the collection of the Museo della natura morta (Still Life Museum) makes it possible to follow a different relationship with the countryside. Fruits, vegetables, flowers and painted objects entered the court collections and gave visual form to the interest in cultivated varieties. The visit to the museum and that to the monumental rooms may involve separate time slots. Between the one and the other, look for the relationship between the nucleus of the villa, the walk around the building and the views towards the low-lying lands.
Artimino offers architecture of a different season. La Ferdinanda, built for Ferdinand I to a design by Bernardo Buontalenti, is recognisable by its many chimneys and by the solid volume that stands out on the ridge. The reference to hunting is understood in the context of the Barco Reale, the territory organised by the court for hunting. Poggio a Caiano and Artimino thus make an effective comparison between the Laurentian fifteenth century and the grand-ducal period. Before setting off, check the access arrangements for La Ferdinanda, tied to the management of the complex, and allow time to see the village and the landscape from public routes.
Pratolino and the water that stages the garden
At Pratolino the best-known element is Giambologna’s Colossus of the Apennines. The great figure emerges beside a stretch of water and changes appearance as it is observed from different angles. Set the view from the bank beside the view from a little further away. The proportion between the sculpture, the trees and the slope changes, and the posture and structure of the group become legible. The sources on the estate repeatedly mention the water games, automata and grottoes designed for the park of Francesco I de’ Medici with Bernardo Buontalenti.
The layout that can be visited belongs to several moments. The works of the Lorraine period and the transformation into a landscape park altered the design of the green areas. Some of the elements recalled in the old descriptions have disappeared or survive in altered forms. The plan of the park helps to distinguish what is visible today from the architecture documented by sources or reconstructions. Set aside specific time for the routes through the greenery and check the seasonal opening hours of the Metropolitan City of Florence, which manages the openings. Pratolino can take up a good part of a half day even for those who mainly wish to see the Apennine.
From Cerreto Guidi to the Apuan Alps
At Cerreto Guidi, the system of ramps leads up to a villa commissioned by Duke Cosimo I and linked to hunting. The building dominates a compact village, so the climb of the ramps should be read together with the streets and the slope of the town. The historical museum of hunting and the territory makes available objects that allow a deeper look at a practice recurring on the Medici estates. The visit gains context if one also looks at what extends beyond the village, where the ground becomes agricultural.
La Magia, at Quarrata, is another useful stop for following the transformations of country properties. The villa passed to the Medici in the sixteenth century and its history includes garden layouts and changes of ownership. Today it forms part of the cultural activities of the municipality. Seravezza, by contrast, leads to the entrance of an Apuan valley. The palace commissioned by Cosimo I is read alongside the watercourses and the productive history of Versilia, with its quarries and marble working. Its location is particularly significant compared with the hill villas of the Florentine territory. A seat of representation could also become a point from which to follow the economic interests of the territory.
Planning the route
For a first day, choose Boboli if the base is in the historic centre of Florence, or a pairing of Castello and La Petraia if the aim is to follow the design of the terraces closely. For the second, set aside time for Poggio a Caiano and choose the next stop according to opening times, between Artimino and La Magia. Pratolino, the Mugello and Seravezza work better with a programme of their own. Use the map to assess the real distances between the entrances, the final uphill stretch and the possibility of returning by public transport.
Before setting off, choose one element to look for again at each stop. It may be the threshold between interior and exterior, the point from which the view opens, or the position of a basin in relation to the slope. A comparison of this kind leaves room for the differences between the public garden, the historic park and the privately managed villa. It also brings the heritage back to its clearest scale. Building, green space and territory are three parts of the same visit, even when only one of them is entered.