The site
Italy, Switzerland. Natural · Inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 2003.
Criteria for inscription
- (viii) Evidence of the history of the Earth or of geological processes and landscape formation
- Number on the List
- 1090
Monte San Giorgio is a rise near Lake Lugano, on the border between Italy and Switzerland. UNESCO recognises it under criterion (viii), that of geological phenomena, because it is the best known reference for Triassic marine life and also preserves terrestrial remains. The fossils are numerous and well preserved, and form the basis for future research.
UNESCO gives a height for the mountain of 1,096 metres. The text consulted does not give the area of the property or the buffer zone, and for this reason the guide gives no figures in square kilometres.
Italy, Switzerland. Natural · Inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 2003.
The site entered the World Heritage List in 2003 with the Swiss part. In 2010 the inscription was extended to the Italian part. According to UNESCO, the extension meets the integrity requirements for a fossil site, because the property includes the entire Middle Triassic outcrop with all the main fossil-bearing areas.
This is why the page carries two flags. The property is a single one, but it crosses the border: the localities are in Switzerland, with Meride, and in Italy, with Besano, Porto Ceresio and Viggiù, according to another source.
UNESCO places the history of the mountain between 245 and 230 million years ago. The mountain preserves the remains of a tropical lagoon sheltered by a coral reef. Another source adds details: the lagoon was 30 to 130 metres deep and 10 to 20 kilometres wide, about 20 degrees north of the equator, with surface water between 22 and 25 degrees and a monsoon-type climate.
The coral reef, the San Salvatore Dolomite, separated the lagoon from the open sea. The seabed was without oxygen, and this explains the preservation: carcasses fell to the bottom and the mud covered them before other organisms could scatter them.
According to other sources consulted the Besano Formation is dated to 242.1 million years, with an uncertainty of 0.6, and belongs to the transition between Upper Anisian and Lower Ladinian. It is 15-16 metres thick and alternates dolomite and bituminous shales. The Meride Limestone is 400-600 metres thick, while the Kalkschieferzone, of the Upper Ladinian, is about 120 metres thick and dated to 239.51 million years. The San Giorgio Dolomite is 60 metres thick.
The organic carbon content in the shales reaches up to 44 per cent, with an average of 4. These are numbers that help to understand why the shales were exploited by industry and why they are so rich in organic remains.
The source gives more than 20,000 finds, with about 25 species of reptiles and 100 of fish. Among the reptiles appear Ticinosuchus ferox, a land reptile reconstructed at 2.5 metres, and Besanosaurus leptorhynchus, an ichthyosaur up to 6 metres. The nothosaurs reach 4 metres, while the pachypleurosaurs measure 30-50 centimetres. Tanystropheus, Ceresiosaurus and the placodont Cyamodus hildegardis are also cited.
Among the fish the genus Saurichthys preserves embryos and digestive tract. Insects are rare and small: Tintorina meridensis, a mayfly of 17 millimetres, and Dasyleptus, of 15. The plants number over 50 finds, mostly conifers of the genus Voltzia. UNESCO lists more generically reptiles, fish, bivalves, ammonites, echinoderms and crustaceans, as well as reptiles, insects and land plants.
Monte San Giorgio preserves whole animals, and sometimes internal organs and embryos, because the oxygen-free seabed prevented decomposition. This is the point that UNESCO calls scientific value: a rich and legible succession of a Middle Triassic marine environment.
For a non-specialist reader it should be borne in mind that the property does not coincide with a museum. The value depends on the accessible rock outcrops and the intact strata, and for this reason authorised scientific excavations and the protection of fossils in situ are central to management.
In 1847 Curioni reported fossil fish in the shales of Besano, and in 1854 Emilio Cornalia published the first scientific paper. In 1863 Antonio Stoppani began the first excavations at Besano. In 1886 Bassani published on the fossils of Besano.
From 1919 Bernhard Peyer began his studies, and in 1924 the excavations of the Palaeontological Museum of the University of Zurich got under way. In 1927 the levels of the Lower and Upper Quarry were discovered. From 1950 to 1968 a campaign at Mirigioli, Point 902, was carried out with the University of Basel. In 1990 Andrea Tintori began excavations in the Kalkschieferzone. The dates come from another source.
The shales did not interest only palaeontologists. Between 1774 and 1790 at Besano there were the first industrial excavations, by Valsecchi. From 1902 in Italy and from 1909 in Switzerland the extraction of the oil called Saurolo began, with a yield of about 8 per cent, that is 74-85 litres per tonne of shale.
The proven reserves were 1.6 million tonnes of shale, equal to 128,000 tonnes of oil. In 1948 the tunnels reached 1,700 metres and there were 34 employees. After the Second World War foreign competition led to the closure of the Meride plant. The product was similar to ichthyol, which was produced at Seefeld, in Austria. On 20 August 1931 an accident in Val Porina cost the life of the worker Giorgio Buzzi.
UNESCO says that the universal value depends on the accessible outcrops and the intact strata. Protection is legal in Italy and Switzerland, with landscape controls applied at local level and supported by national, regional and provincial governments.
Cross-border cooperation rests on agreements signed by the municipalities of the two countries and on a joint management plan. There is staff dedicated to management in both countries. The collections are kept in universities and museums, and there are visitor centres and communication programmes. UNESCO does not treat authenticity explicitly and does not list specific threats: it indicates as a management requirement balancing the difficulty of access to the fossil areas with the need to allow legal scientific excavations.
The Fossil Museum of Meride, in Switzerland, was inaugurated on 13 October 2012. Renovated by Mario Botta, it is on four floors. In Italy there is the Civic Fossil Museum of Besano. The collections are also at the Natural History Museum of Milan, the Palaeontological Museum of the University of Zurich, the Cantonal Museum of Natural History in Lugano and the Insubric Civic Museum of Natural History in Induno Olona.
The geo-palaeontological trail measures 13.5 kilometres and takes about 4 and a half hours, starting from the church of San Silvestro in Meride. The sources cite a geo-guide with a hiking map. For opening times, museum hours and trail conditions it is advisable to consult the official websites before setting off.
UNESCO places the property near Lake Lugano and gives a single height, 1,096 metres. Another source, instead, cites altitudes of routes, such as 650 metres for the cable car, 771 at Gaggio and 812 at Pozzo, without giving the height of the summit. These are data of a different nature and must not be confused.
Dates too must be read with care. The years next to the names of species in the source’s bibliography are those of the reference publication, not those of discovery. The same goes for localities: the source names Besano, Porto Ceresio and Viggiù for Italy and Meride for Switzerland, but the list does not claim to be complete.
The source’s bibliography makes it possible to date some scientific descriptions. Tanystropheus longobardicus and Ceresiosaurus calcagnii date from 1931, Paraplacodus broilii from the same year, and Askeptosaurus italicus from 1925. Ticinosuchus ferox is from 1965, Cymbospondylus buchseri from 1989, Mikadocephalus gracilirostris from 1997, Sangiorgiosaurus from 1998 and the crustacean Meridecaris ladinica from 2013.
The sequence shows that research is not finished. A first phase of descriptions falls in the 1920s and 1930s, a second comes in the 1960s, and new species still appear after 1990 and in the twenty-first century. The site therefore remains an open laboratory, and not a closed archive.
UNESCO speaks of agreements between the municipalities of the two countries and of a joint management plan. The local sources cited by another source include the Municipality of Meride, the Patriziato of Arzo and the official website of the mountain. In 2014 the Monte San Giorgio Foundation, based in Meride, published the museum guides.
The nomination dossier was prepared in 2002 by the Swiss Federal Agency for the Environment, Forests and Landscape. For the Italian extension the source cites a report by the same agency of 2010 and a volume published by the Italian National Commission for UNESCO in 2015.
The guide suggests dividing the visit into three levels. The museum makes it possible to see the finds and to understand the lagoon environment. The geo-palaeontological trail lets the rocks be read in the open air, and the Italian museums, such as that of Besano, show the southern part of the property.
Since the value lies in the strata and not in individual objects, it is advisable to avoid collecting fossils or rock fragments. Excavations are authorised and scientific, and a find removed out of context loses its value. It is better to photograph, note the place and report any finds to the local authorities.
Monte San Giorgio is a reminder that a natural property does not follow administrative borders. The fossil-bearing strata continue from one country to the other, and for this reason protection requires coordinated rules, staff and plans in Italy and Switzerland. UNESCO counts it among the strengths of management.
For visitors the border has practical consequences: museums, opening times and access rules are different in the two countries, and a complete itinerary requires consulting several official websites. It is advisable to plan in advance and not to assume that information valid at Meride also holds at Besano.
The sources on Monte San Giorgio speak of museums, trails and a property that crosses the border between Italy and Switzerland. For a useful reading it is advisable to hold three elements together: the Triassic fossils, the landscape of the mountain and the places where the finds are displayed.
The property is better understood by distinguishing what is on the mountain from what is in the museums. The sources list neither opening times nor prices, and for practical information they refer to the museums and the managing bodies.
For Monte San Giorgio the sources mix summit heights and route altitudes, and years of discovery with years of publication. The guide keeps them distinct.
Between 245 and 230 million years ago the fossil deposit is formed. In 1847 Curioni reports the fish of Besano, in 1863 Stoppani begins the excavations and in 1924 the Zurich campaign starts. In 1902 and 1909 oil extraction begins in the two countries, and in 1990 Tintori begins excavations in the Kalkschieferzone.
In 2003 the Swiss part enters World Heritage, and in 2010 the inscription is extended to Italy. On 13 October 2012 the Meride museum is inaugurated.