About 220 monuments in a stone enclosure
The official description speaks of about 220 historic monuments. Some are the most famous buildings in the world. The Dome of the Rock is of the seventh century and bears geometric and floral decorations; Collins dates it to around 691 and calls it one of the oldest Islamic monuments still in existence. The Rotunda of the Resurrection, in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, houses the tomb of Christ. The Western Wall marks the boundary between the quarters of the different religious communities.
The walls and the gates
The walls seen today were commissioned by the Ottoman sultan Suleiman the Magnificent. A Jewish virtual library dates the works between 1537 and 1541 and notes that the Jaffa Gate is of 1538 and the Zion Gate, the last built, of 1540. The perimeter is about 4 km (a figure converted on this page from the unit of length used by the source) and counts 11 gates, of which 7 are open: Jaffa, Zion, Dung, Lions’ (St Stephen’s), Herod’s, Damascus and New. The Golden Gate is among those closed.
Near the Jaffa Gate stands the Citadel, with the Tower of David, whose cylindrical appearance dates from the sixteenth century; beside it, a taller square tower, of the Herodian period, is about two thousand years old.
The four quarters
The city is divided into four quarters: Christian, Armenian, Muslim and Jewish. The Armenian is the smallest, about a sixth of the area. Each has its own places: in the Jewish quarter are the Hurva synagogue, the Ramban synagogue, the Cardo and an archaeological museum; in the Armenian one the church and monastery of St James. The Western Wall, about 20 m high, stands at the base of the Temple Mount, which Muslims call Haram ash-Sharif, an area of about 0.16 km² (a figure converted on this page from the unit of area used by the source) on which stand the Dome of the Rock and the al-Aqsa mosque.
For those on foot, the best-known route is the Via Dolorosa, with 14 stations: the first seven in the Muslim quarter, the last five inside the Holy Sepulchre.
A history as long as the city
Collins tells the sacred history of the city. The First Temple, built on Mount Moriah by King Solomon and completed in 957 BC, was destroyed in 586 BC by Nebuchadnezzar II of Babylon. The Second Temple was completed in 515 BC and enlarged by Herod the Great; the Western Wall was part of the supporting structure of the platform. The Romans destroyed it in AD 70 and founded Aelia Capitolina. From the fourth century the Christian period was among the most peaceful and prosperous, and the Holy Sepulchre, completed in 335, marks according to tradition the place of the crucifixion, tomb and resurrection of Jesus. From 638 the city was under the Arab Islamic empire.
In 969 control passed to the Fatimids, and a season of conflict and destruction, with a ban on pilgrimage for Christians, contributed to the Crusades; the Christian conquest of 1099 turned the Dome of the Rock into a Christian sanctuary, the Templum Domini, and led to the rebuilding of the Holy Sepulchre and the founding of hospices and monasteries. According to Collins the symbolic importance of the city for three religions has provoked struggles for power lasting centuries.
A nomination and a political case
Jerusalem is a particular case on the List: the property was proposed by Jordan and appears on the List as a “site proposed by Jordan”. The Committee inscribed it in 1981 and placed it among the properties in danger in 1982. In the documents of 2010 and 2011 it is stated that, because of the political context, the “desired state of conservation” that would allow the property to be removed from the list of properties in danger had not been set: only individual activities are possible, as parts of an action plan.
How it is protected
The sources describe protection divided among several parties. Israel reports conservation works on the monuments and the walls; Jordan describes the restorations by the Muslim religious administration, the Waqf, on the Esplanade. UNESCO follows the property with a reinforced monitoring mechanism, which asks for periodic reports, in particular on the access ramp known as the Mughrabi, and with expert missions: they number between 2004 and 2009. Since 1988 about 4 million United States dollars of extrabudgetary funds have arrived. The UNESCO action plan exists, but is carried out only in parts and depends on donors.
The threats
The Committee justified the placement among the properties in danger with two reasons: an ascertained danger, that is, the loss of authenticity and cultural significance, and a potential danger, that is, weakened legal protection, the absence of a conservation policy and urban planning that threatens the property. Among the issues noted over time are weak planning and land governance, the alteration of the urban and social fabric, the effects of archaeological excavations, the deterioration of monuments, damage to the urban landscape and problems of traffic and access.
On many of these issues the parties hold opposing positions. In 2010 Israel reported revitalisation plans, conservation of the monuments and walls, rescue excavations and building works, among them the Western Wall plaza and the Zion Gate; Jordan contested excavations, limits on access for experts, excavation works near al-Aqsa and demographic changes. The Committee asked Israel for more information on the excavations and all parties to avoid unilateral actions affecting authenticity and integrity.
Figures that do not add up
Figures always vary, and for Jerusalem too they are given all the same to convey an idea. One language version of the official description speaks of about 1 km² for the Old City, while the English one gives no area; a virtual library gives the area in non-metric units, which converted make about 0.9 km², and then rounds it to 1 km². In short, a little rounding has never hurt any ancient city.
What the sources do not say
The sources consulted give no opening hours, prices or visiting rules and refer to the official sites. The boundaries, the buffer zone, integrity, authenticity and a precise area are missing.
In brief
Cultural site number 148, inscribed in 1981 on Jordan’s proposal under criteria (ii), (iii) and (vi), and in danger since 1982. About 1 km² of Old City, about 220 monuments, walls of about 4 km with 11 gates, four quarters.
Before departure
For a journey to Israel and the Palestinian Territories, the page of the country on Viaggiare Sicuri, the service of the Italian Foreign Ministry (Farnesina), should be consulted for up-to-date advisories. For visiting conditions it is best to contact the local authorities and the official UNESCO website.
Key dates
- 1537Start of Suleiman’s Ottoman walls (until 1541)
- 1981Inscription on the World Heritage List, on Jordan’s proposal
- 1982Placement on the List of World Heritage in Danger
- 2010The Committee confirms the property among those in danger