A railway bridge between Edinburgh and Fife

At South Queensferry, on the southern shore of the Firth of Forth, the railway bridge is recognised by its three great red structures. They have a wide base and, each starting from a support, advance towards the neighbouring structures. A train in transit makes height and length perceptible. To the west two road bridges can be seen, belonging to another technical history. The presence of all three in the same stretch of estuary offers a rare opportunity to compare designs born over more than a century. The Forth Bridge declared a World Heritage Site in 2015 is the railway bridge opened in 1890, between South Queensferry, in the Edinburgh area, and North Queensferry, in Fife.

The bridge measures about two and a half kilometres and retains a daily transport function. The UNESCO inscription recognises the creative achievement and its place in the development of railway infrastructure. From the shore the main elements of this achievement can be seen clearly. The silhouette derives from the organisation of the supports, the girders and the connections needed to carry the track. To read it, it is advisable to alternate between two distances. From afar the sequence of the spans is recognised. From beneath one of the approach structures, the relationships between the thickness of the members, the joints and the line of the railway become visible.

The site

United Kingdom. Cultural · Inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 2015.

Criteria for inscription

  • (i) A masterpiece of human creative genius
  • (iv) An outstanding example of architecture, technology or landscape illustrating a significant stage in history
Number on the List
1485

How the structure works

A cantilever is an element that projects beyond its support. In the Forth Bridge the load-bearing structure extends in two directions from each of the main towers. The ends of two neighbouring structures receive a lighter suspended section. Looking at a complete span, the distance between the towers therefore comprises cantilever portions and an element between their ends. The track remains continuous along the whole structure. The form may recall three separate units, while the path of the loads involves supports and connections arranged along the estuary.

It is advisable to recognise first one of the towers and follow its lines towards the centre of the span. The components have very different sections. The great steel tubes, formed from plates, are used in the elements that work mainly in compression. Thinner elements take part in the structure at the points that work in tension. The diagonals contribute to rigidity in an environment exposed to wind. Observe then how two large profiles meet over a relatively short, thin stretch. This is the point at which one understands that the same railway rests on elements with distinct tasks.

In a famous photograph of 1887 three men simulate the principle of the structure. Two seated figures, resting on chairs and facing each other, support a central element with their arms. Behind them the counterweights can be seen. The image makes the general arrangement intuitive, while the bridge as built required calculations for trains, wind and temperature variation. The analogy works well if one looks again at a span from the waterfront and seeks the line of the track. From there one can follow the passage of the loads towards the great towers and the stone foundations.

From the rail ferry to the design of Fowler and Baker

Before the bridge it was already possible to continue beyond the Forth thanks to a rail ferry. From 1850 the link between Granton and Burntisland carried carriages on a ship designed for this function. The practice shows how far the national network depended on the points of discontinuity imposed by water. The bridge at Queensferry would establish another route and a continuity for trains along the east coast. The crossing moved between two places where the island of Inchgarvie could contribute to the choice of line and the distribution of the supports.

Thomas Bouch had prepared the design of a suspension bridge over the Forth. The collapse of the Tay Bridge in December 1879 halted work on the Forth and led to the abandonment of that design. The system that followed arose to satisfy together the demands of navigation and the requirements of rigidity, load and safety of a railway line. The design that was built was developed by John Fowler and Benjamin Baker. The construction contract went to the firm of William Arrol. The great spans left a passage free for ships, while the railway had to bear the weight of trains and cope with variable stresses.

The choice to use mild steel on so large a scale makes the bridge important in the history of materials. Building with thousands of tonnes of plate meant producing pieces with shapes and joints suited to the forces they would meet. The silhouette of the bridge sums up many decisions that the shore makes difficult to see individually. In the upper part members and lattices can be distinguished, while at the foot of the towers the mass of the foundations can be sensed. The perception changes when one looks closely at the relationship between a tube, the plates that make it up and the regular pattern of the rivets.

The foundations and the work of the Briggers

The construction site lasted for much of the 1880s. Before the towers could rise above the water level, the foundations had to be built in the estuary. Large caissons were used, brought into position and lowered onto the bearing points. In the pneumatic ones, compressed air made it possible to create a space in which to work below the water level. The modernity of the bridge begins from this little-visible part. A support placed badly or on an unsuitable base would have had consequences for the position of the track and for the assembly of structures hundreds of metres apart.

The towers were then raised above the granite supports. The elements of the cantilevers advanced progressively towards the centre of the spans. The growing site had to stay in balance even before acquiring its final configuration. Historic photographs show that stage with particular clarity. One sees structures extending from a support into the void and, in the following years, the space progressively filled. Before the inauguration, tests with heavy trains and measurements of the bridge’s response verified how the system behaved under load.

The workforce was known as the Briggers. At the peak of the work the site employed about 4,600 men, according to the operator’s documentation. Local research recalled by The Forth Bridges has reconstructed 73 deaths connected with the construction. The memorial dedicated to the workers makes it possible to restore the perspective of the people to a visit that begins from the proportions of the steel. Reading their names and then returning to observe the levels of the bridge helps to link the design to the toil of the assembly. The official opening, on 4 March 1890, took place in the presence of the Prince of Wales, the future Edward VII.

The red, the riveting and the maintenance

The red is one of the elements that make the bridge recognisable from the surrounding territory. A steel element exposed in an estuary requires inspections and protection from corrosion. Maintaining the surface means working on a structure with dense joints, large tubes and components placed at different heights. The traditional tale of the never-ending painting arises from the scale of the work itself. Modern programmes have changed materials and methods. The refurbishment project that Network Rail declares completed in 2011 involved a long intervention on the surfaces and the use of a protective system designed to last longer than the earlier cycles.

Maintenance offers a key to understanding the meaning of a UNESCO site still in use. Trains continue to use the bridge, and the structure has to be inspected, repaired and managed under the rules of the contemporary railway. The historic value also lies in the way the design continues to perform its task. Watching a train from the ground, one sees together a nineteenth-century infrastructure and a modern network that makes use of its capacity to cross. At the points closest to the shore, the rivets and the geometry of the joints can be made out without crossing the boundaries of the railway property.

Three bridges over the same stretch of water

The Forth Road Bridge, opened in 1964, is the great suspension crossing seen to the west of the railway bridge. Further on stands the Queensferry Crossing, opened in 2017, with its cables fanned out along the towers, some of them crossing. All three can be recognised without knowing the specialist terminology. On the bridge of 1890 the great lattices of steel are plain to see. On the suspension bridge, the main cable forms a continuous curve from which vertical elements hang. On the most recent bridge, the stay cables run directly between the towers and the roadway.

From a point where the crossings are seen one behind the other, the structures seem to occupy the same line. Moving along the shore, the distances can be told apart. Look at the stretch between two great supports of each bridge. One sees the form of the structure that carries the deck, its thickness and the point at which the forces are carried downwards. Even the way the bridge appears from afar depends on these choices. The three silhouettes document different ways of carrying people and goods over the same kind of obstacle.

Viewpoints at South Queensferry

From the centre of South Queensferry one can begin on the waterfront, among the open views towards the three bridges and the glimpses that open at the end of the alleys. The railway bridge appears to the east of the road crossings. Continuing towards Hawes Pier the angle changes, and the relationship between the structure and the southern shore can be seen better. The walk along the historic centre also has the advantage that it can be shortened or extended on the spur of the moment, depending on the light, the wind or the time available. The perimeter of the railway remains distinct from the public spaces from which the structures are observed.

The Forth Bridges Viewpoint, at the southern end of the Forth Road Bridge, makes it possible to put the view back together. Before arriving, one can consult the map of the local route and decide whether to continue towards the walkway of the road bridge, checking any notices from the operator. Take into account the ramps, the actual distance and the exposure. Dalmeny railway station serves the village, but it lies above the level of the waterfront. To build an itinerary with children or with reduced mobility, it is advisable to assess the differences in level between the station and the viewpoints, as well as the availability of other connections.

The piers before and after the bridge

The piers of Queensferry preserve the memory of a crossing older than the railway. Local documentation reports links between the two shores dating back to the Middle Ages, along routes that also led to St Andrews. The name of the places itself recalls the ferry. When the landings were improved in the early nineteenth century and new boats arrived, the shores underwent a transformation distinct from the one that, decades later, would bring the railway. At North Queensferry the small lighthouse built by Robert Stevenson in 1817 stands near the Town Pier. Its modest volume clarifies the scale that the ferry services must have had, while the towers of the bridge make it possible to measure how much the size of investments has changed.

The ferry between the two villages remained in service even after the opening of the railway bridge and was superseded by the road crossing in the 1960s. Those who continue towards the piers can therefore follow three overlapping stories. The first concerns the landings and the route between the two settlements. The second follows the railway at height, far from the services of the pier. The third belongs to road mobility. The walking distance between the shore and the station makes it possible to see these differences on the ground. On the waterfront it remains easy to imagine the arrival of the boats, while the track crosses the estuary directly, at a height that leaves room for navigation.

North Queensferry and the crossing by train

On the opposite shore, at North Queensferry, the bridge dominates the small village and the streets that climb towards the station. The points near the water allow the structure to be viewed towards the south, with the succession of spans against the background of the estuary. For those arriving from the southern village, the comparison between these two views is worth as much as the crossing. The distribution of the towers is seen at a distance, and the components change in apparent size on approach. The scale of the settlement of North Queensferry is also better understood by turning towards the village after looking at the bridge.

On foot, the crossing of the pedestrian route of the Forth Road Bridge can be planned according to the conditions published by the operator. The Forth Bridge is for rail use. To cross it, choose a ScotRail service stopping at Dalmeny or at North Queensferry and check timetables and stops for the chosen date. From the window the steel close to the tracks alternates with the broader view over the estuary. One stretch may offer only quick glimpses, so the journey works better after observing the bridge from the ground. If there is time for only one shore, a walk between the centre of South Queensferry and the eastern front of the harbour still makes it possible to read supports, spans and access to the railway in a single sequence.

Map of the site

© OpenStreetMap · ODbL

Sources and references