Cultural heritage · 2015

Arab-Norman Palermo and the Cathedral Churches of Cefalù and Monreale

What UNESCO protects

The serial property brings together nine religious and civil structures from the period of the Norman Kingdom of Sicily (1130-1194), on the northern coast of the island: the cathedrals of Cefalù and Monreale and seven buildings in the capital Palermo. They are the Royal Palace with the Palatine Chapel, the Zisa Palace, the Palermo Cathedral, San Giovanni degli Eremiti, Santa Maria dell’Ammiraglio, San Cataldo and the Admiral’s Bridge. UNESCO gives a total area of 62.35 square kilometres and distinguishes two levels of buffer zone, without stating their extent.

There are two criteria. Criterion (ii) recognises the coexistence of peoples of different origins, from which a new style was born that influenced the architecture of the Tyrrhenian side of southern Italy and spread through the medieval Mediterranean. Criterion (iv) sees in it an exceptional example of stylistic synthesis, which created new spatial, constructive and decorative concepts. According to other sources consulted, the inscription dates from 3 July 2015, during the 39th session of the Committee in Bonn.

The site

. Cultural · Inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 2015.

Places within the UNESCO perimeter

  • Zisa Palace
  • Palermo Cathedral
  • Cefalù Cathedral
  • Admiral’s Bridge
  • Monreale Cathedral
  • Church of San Cataldo

See all 9 stops on the map

Criteria for inscription

  • (ii) Exchange of ideas and techniques that influenced architecture, the arts, town planning or landscape
  • (iv) An outstanding example of architecture, technology or landscape illustrating a significant stage in history
Number on the List
1487

Nine components, three cities

The property brings together buildings in Palermo and the cathedrals of Cefalù and Monreale. In the city it comprises the Royal Palace and Palatine Chapel, the Cathedral, San Giovanni degli Eremiti, Santa Maria dell’Ammiraglio, San Cataldo, the Zisa and the Admiral’s Bridge. This ensemble makes it possible to observe religious works, residences and infrastructure of the same period. It is useful to look at how arches, carved stone and mosaics are used in different contexts, rather than seeking a single identical style in every building.

Three cultures in one kingdom

UNESCO speaks of a socio-cultural syncretism between Western, Islamic and Byzantine cultures. In practice this means that in the same building there are arches and volumes of Latin tradition, decoration and ceilings of Islamic taste, and mosaics of Byzantine school on a gold ground. The visit should be read with this key: the aim is not to find a pure style, but to see how different craftsmen worked for the same patron.

According to other sources consulted, the nomination was promoted in 2010 by the Fondazione Patrimonio UNESCO Sicilia and the Regional Department of Cultural Heritage. The Region asked to extend the route to other places, including the Castello a Mare, the Cuba, the Cubula, the Castello di Maredolce, the Magione and the baths of Cefalà Diana, but the text does not say whether they are already included in the inscription: for now the guide does not include them.

The Palatine Chapel: dates and measurements

According to another source, the Palatine Chapel was commissioned by Roger II. Work began in 1129, the consecration took place on 28 April 1140 at the hands of Archbishop Roger Fesca and the inauguration on 29 June 1143. The church measures 33 metres in length and 13 in width. A first underground sanctuary, the church of Santa Maria di Gerusalemme, is dated to 1117.

The wooden muqarnas ceiling was made by masters of the Fatimid and Iranian schools. In the coffers there are Kufic inscriptions and plant and animal ornaments, with scenes of hunting, war and love, musicians, dancers and chess players.

Norman Palace and Palatine Chapel

In the Palatine Chapel the mosaics and the wooden ceiling belong to the same composition. The light of the nave makes the gilded surfaces alternate with the dark structure above the arcades. To pause in front of a detail, follow the rhythm of the visit and look for a few significant points rather than photographing the whole hall. The relationship with the palace clarifies the use of the chapel as a space tied to the court. From here it is possible to continue to San Giovanni degli Eremiti and climb back towards the Cathedral, taking account of the opening hours of the individual places.

Mosaics in several phases

The Byzantine mosaics cover the dome, the transept and the apses. In the Norman phase, Roger II had the crossing, dome and apses executed, William I the cycle of Genesis and William II the side aisles with the stories of Peter and Paul. A later phase, of the Bourbon period, includes interventions of 1716, completed in 1719, and an external cycle commissioned by Ferdinand III.

UNESCO states that the authenticity of the mosaics was confirmed by experts in Byzantine mosaics. As regards restorations, the source recalls that after the 2002 earthquake the work was completed in July 2008, with funding of more than three million euros from the patron Reinhold Würth.

San Giovanni degli Eremiti

According to other sources consulted, the monastery goes back to a first settlement of 581, with Gregory the Great and his mother Silvia among the promoters, and it was destroyed by the Saracens in 842. In the Arab period the site housed an Islamic building, probably a mosque, with a hall measuring 17.76 by 5.62 metres oriented towards Mecca. The reconstruction was ordered by King Roger in 1132 and the monastery was entrusted to William of Vercelli. The date should be checked against primary sources.

The red domes were restored in the nineteenth century by the architect Giuseppe Patricolo, on the basis of traces of dark red plaster, and around 1880 Patricolo himself removed later additions. The cloister, with paired columns and acanthus-leaf capitals, is the best preserved part of the monastery and has an Arab cistern. The interior has three semicircular apses and five square bays covered by small domes.

Piazza Bellini, Zisa and the bridge

Santa Maria dell’Ammiraglio, known as the Martorana, and San Cataldo offer an immediate comparison from the square. In the first, several decorative layers and mosaics can be recognised, while the second helps to read volumes and domes clearly. The Zisa requires a separate outing and introduces the relationship between residence, garden and water. The Admiral’s Bridge brings the visit to an infrastructure and invites the reconstruction of the historic watercourse even when the present context looks very different.

Palermo Cathedral

The cathedral was promoted by Archbishop Walter Ophamil in 1170 and completed between 1184 and 1185, with consecration on 6 April 1185, according to other sources. The earthquake of 4 February 1169 had damaged the bell tower and the façade, and was the pretext for the reconstruction. After the Arab conquest the church had been transformed into a great mosque, able to hold 7,000 worshippers, and under the Normans the minaret became a bell tower.

Between 1767 and 1781 Archbishop Filangieri entrusted Ferdinando Fuga with a consolidation project. The great restoration lasted from 1781 to 1801 and was carried out by Carlo Chenchi with Giuseppe Venanzio Marvuglia. The interior was remodelled: the columns became pillars, the pointed arches were replaced by round arches and sixteen small domes were added over the side aisles. The present dome is from that intervention.

The royal tombs and Saint Rosalia

Sovereigns and their relatives rest in the cathedral. In 1215 Frederick II had two porphyry sarcophagi brought from Cefalù, intended for himself and his father Henry VI. Constance of Hauteville, mother of Frederick II, has been buried since 1198 in a porphyry sarcophagus under a white marble canopy. Constance of Aragon, who died in 1222, has a sarcophagus of the Roman era with a hunting scene. Roger II, who died in 1154, was buried in Palermo in a simpler porphyry sarcophagus.

The cathedral also preserves the cult of Saint Rosalia. The source states that her body was found on 15 July 1624, during the plague, and that on 27 July of the same year the saint was proclaimed patron of Palermo. The silver urn, of the seventeenth century, was made between 1631 and 1637 and is carried in procession on 15 July. The first Festino took place on 15 July 1625.

Monreale: the cathedral in numbers

According to other sources consulted, the cathedral was founded by William II, King of Sicily from 1166 to 1189. Work began in 1172 and the solemn consecration took place on 25 April 1267, under Charles of Anjou, about 95 years after the start. In August 1926 Pope Pius XI raised it to the rank of minor basilica. The plan is a Latin cross with three naves and two rows of nine Corinthian columns of grey granite, one of which is of cipollino.

Much of the building is covered with mosaics of Byzantine school on a gold ground, executed between the twelfth and the mid-thirteenth century. The source gives about 300 square metres of wall bands, 975 square metres of floor in the presbytery and an apse conch with the Christ Pantocrator measuring 13 metres by 7. The text does not give the number of tesserae, so the guide does not report it.

Bronze doors and cloister

There are two bronze doors. The one on the north side is attributed to Barisano da Trani and datable to around 1185. The one on the façade is the work of Bonanno Pisano, of 1185-1186. The cloister was built at the end of the twelfth century, has a square plan 47 metres on a side and a portico with pointed arches of double ring.

The capitals are attributed to five groups of artists, for a total of 216 (34, 30, 70, 40 and 42). For visitors it is a place where it is worth slowing down: each side has a different sequence of figures and motifs.

Monreale and Cefalù

At Monreale it is worth devoting time to both the church and the cloister. Inside, the arrangement of the figures on the walls creates a narrative to be followed zone by zone, while in the cloister the work on the capitals has a scale suited to close viewing. At Cefalù the Duomo reads well by comparing the façade on the square with the interior spaces and the mosaic of the apse. The town requires a longer transfer from Palermo. To visit it at leisure, a separate day can be devoted to it.

Cefalù: from foundation to mosaics

The chronology of Cefalù is the best documented. Work began in 1131 and, probably, in 1145 the mosaics of the apse and crossing were begun, executed by Byzantine masters summoned by Roger II. By 1148 a first phase was complete, with an inscription naming Roger II and that date, while a second phase falls between 1154 and 1166.

Tradition attributes the origin to a vow to the Most Holy Saviour after a narrow escape from shipwreck. According to the source, the real motive was instead to build a dynastic church with two towers and a westwork of Carolingian-Norman tradition. The official consecration is of 10 April 1267, the same year as the consecration of Monreale.

The Pantocrator and the rest of the building

The apse mosaic shows Christ Pantocrator with the open Gospel and inscriptions in Greek and Latin. Below appear the Virgin orant with four archangels, and then saints, evangelists and apostles. The mosaics exceed 600 square metres. The interior has fourteen columns of pink granite and two of cipollino, reused, with capitals of the second century AD.

In the fifteenth century the three-arched portico by Ambrogio da Como and the spires of the towers, one square and one octagonal in plan, were added. The restorations of the mosaics in 1860 involved heavy alterations, while those of 2001 are more recent. The cloister was restored until 2003. The church has been a national monument since 1941.

Three interiors to compare

In the Palatine Chapel the longitudinal hall, the mosaics and the wooden muqarnas ceiling bring together different techniques and traditions. The ceiling requires looking up along the nave. The sanctuary area, by contrast, concentrates gilded coverings and figures. At Monreale, the scale of the apse and the extent of the mosaics along the walls place the narrative in a far larger building. The cloister deserves a separate stop because capitals and columns are read from close range.

At Cefalù the impact of Christ Pantocrator also depends on its high position in the apse, which dominates the space of the cathedral. Looking from mid-nave and then from close up, at the permitted limit, gives two different perceptions of the mosaic. The three interiors make a particularly clear comparison because each combines decoration and architecture on its own scale.

Integrity, authenticity and protection

UNESCO observes that the property includes all the elements necessary to express its value and that authenticity is expressed in location, setting, forms, materials and functions. The nine components belong to different governmental and religious bodies and enjoy the highest level of protection under the 2004 Code of Cultural Heritage. Three are national monuments: San Giovanni degli Eremiti, Santa Maria dell’Ammiraglio and Monreale Cathedral.

A Memorandum of Understanding defines the management system and the management plan. A Steering Committee, with representatives of owners, managers and institutions, sets the annual activities, and the Fondazione Sicilia UNESCO Heritage carries them out.

Risks and pressures

Among the long-term threats UNESCO cites acts of vandalism, thefts and fires, deterioration linked to mass tourism, including cruise ships, environmental disasters such as earthquakes, landslides, floods and pollution, and the socio-economic decline of historic centres. Monuments at seismic risk are the most exposed.

For the visitor this means respecting the access rules, which change from one component to another, and always checking the managers’ channels, because the nine buildings have different owners.

A possible route

The first day can link Palazzo dei Normanni, San Giovanni degli Eremiti, the Cathedral and Piazza Bellini. On a second day it is possible to choose Monreale and one stop in Palermo. Cefalù works well as an independent excursion. The buildings are managed by different bodies and may have different opening hours, tickets and access arrangements, to be checked before combining the stops.

Key dates

  1. 1129Start of the Palatine Chapel
  2. 1131Start of work at Cefalù
  3. 1140Consecration of the Palatine Chapel (28 April)
  4. 1172Start of work at Monreale
  5. 1185Consecration of Palermo Cathedral
  6. 1267Consecration of Monreale and Cefalù
  7. 1781-1801Restoration of Palermo Cathedral
  8. 2008End of the restoration of the Palatine Chapel
  9. 2015Inscription on the UNESCO List

UNESCO source

Map of the site

© OpenStreetMap · ODbL

Sources and references