The two criteria
The property is inscribed under two cultural criteria. Criterion (iii) recognises in its buildings eloquent testimony to its sombre history. Criterion (vi) links the island and its prisons to the triumph of the human spirit, of freedom and of democracy over oppression.
There are ten UNESCO criteria: (i) to (vi) concern cultural value, (vii) to (x) natural value. Here both criteria are cultural.
Where it is and how large it is
Another source places the island in Table Bay, about 6.9 kilometres from the coast at Bloubergstrand, north of Cape Town, and also says that it lies 11 kilometres from Cape Town. It is roughly oval in shape, about 3.3 kilometres long and 1.9 wide, and flat, rising only a few metres above sea level.
The area is 5.18 square kilometres in the table of the entry and 5.08 in the text. UNESCO gives no surface area and only specifies a buffer zone of one nautical mile.
From discovery to sheep
Another source recalls that in 1488 Bartolomeu Dias sighted the island and that Portuguese, English and Dutch sailors then used it for supplies. In 1654 the Dutch settlers of the Cape Colony put sheep and rams there, collected sealskins and seal oil and released rabbits as a source of meat.
From the late 17th century it was used for detention. Among the first prisoners the entry names Autshumato and Malagasy leaders of the Meermin mutiny. In 1781 the kings and princes of Ternate and Tidore, held by the Dutch, were transferred to Saldanha Bay after the British capture.
Prison, whaling, leper colony
In 1806 the Scottish whaler John Murray opened a whaling station in what became Murray’s Bay. In 1819 the Xhosa chief Makanda Nxele was sentenced to life imprisonment on the island and drowned after an escape attempt.
From 1845 the island was a leper colony, with compulsory confinement after the law of 1892. In the Second World War it was fortified with coastal defence guns.
The apartheid era
The entry says that in 1961 the island became a prison for political prisoners and common criminals under apartheid. UNESCO speaks of a maximum-security prison begun in the 1960s. The Japanese and Dutch sections of UNESCO give 1959 for the opening and 1991 for the release of the last political prisoners.
The Japanese section speaks of about 3,000 people imprisoned over 32 years, from 1959 to 1991. The medium-security prison for common criminals closed in 1996, which according to UNESCO was also the year it was declared a national monument.
Nelson Mandela and the other prisoners
According to other sources consulted, Mandela was held on the island for 18 of his 27 years in prison. The Dutch section of UNESCO speaks of more than 20 years. He later won the Nobel Peace Prize and was South Africa’s first Black president, from 1994 to 1999.
Among other former prisoners the entry names Kgalema Motlanthe, president in 2008-2009, and Jacob Zuma, president from 2009 to 2018. Ahmed Kathrada was imprisoned from 1964 to 1982. In 1982 Indres Naidoo published Island in Chains.
An island of faith
UNESCO mentions the grave of Hadije Kramat, who died in 1755. Another source adds that the Muslim shrine Moturu Kramat was built in 1969.
The entry also notes that the land belongs to the South African state, except for the island’s church. In the nineteenth-century village UNESCO names a chapel and a parsonage, and the leper church.
Integrity
UNESCO says that the remains reflect the island’s history from the 17th century and carry the attributes that convey its value. After the Department of Correctional Services left, little routine maintenance was carried out.
The island’s database lists more than 700 buildings and sites, and unoccupied structures are exposed to decay. There are marine and terrestrial threats, natural and human, partly owing to a lack of clear controls, facilities and direction. Growing visitor numbers add pressure, and funds have favoured works and infrastructure over preventive maintenance.
Authenticity
Authenticity is described as total. The island changed use several times without deliberate conservation, and the different layers reflect its history from the early 17th century and the related events.
This is a particular notion of authenticity, arising from the fact that the places were not restored to a single period. The value lies in accumulation.
Protection and management
The island was declared a national monument in 1996 under the South African national monuments act and is protected by a buffer zone of one nautical mile. UNESCO lists the laws of 1999, 1998, 2004 and 2003 on heritage, the World Heritage Convention, cultural institutions, the environment, biodiversity and protected areas.
Under the protected areas act, mining and prospecting are prohibited in the property and in the buffer zone. The management authority is the Council of the Robben Island Museum, and the chief executive officer oversees day-to-day management and conservation.
Conservation priorities
UNESCO speaks of progress in implementing the Integrated Conservation Management Plan, especially in physical and preventive conservation, interpretation, visitor management and cooperation with the Department of Public Works.
The institutional and management aspects remain to be strengthened, and the recommendations of the June 2003 report of the Department of Public Works, which surveyed the infrastructure, assessed its condition and proposed repairs, remain to be implemented.
A visit to the island
Another source says that the island is run by the Robben Island Museum as a living museum, with many guides who are former prisoners. Ferries leave from the Victoria & Alfred Waterfront in Cape Town, and the tours, three a day, last about 3.5 hours and include Mandela’s cell and the maximum-security prison.
The island is open all year, weather permitting. For many Black South Africans it is “a symbol of oppression”. The entry gives 116 residents in the 2011 census.
Wildlife and environment
African penguins had disappeared from the island by 1800. A new colony formed in 1983 and reached about 16,000 individuals in 2004, before falling to about 3,000 in 2015, probably because of competition with fishing for food.
Rabbits, introduced around 1654, numbered about 25,000 at the beginning of the 21st century and are culled as an invasive species. The 2022 IPCC report includes the island among African cultural sites threatened by flooding and coastal erosion.
Sea, shipwrecks and lighthouse
The entry notes more than 31 vessels wrecked around the island, and Whale Rock, which does not break the surface, increases the danger. The Robben Island lighthouse was completed in 1865 on Minto Hill, once Fire Hill.
UNESCO cites a small lighthouse among the surviving structures, without giving its date.
Where the sources differ
On the area: 5.18 square kilometres in the table of the entry and 5.08 in the text. On the distance: 6.9 kilometres from the coast at Bloubergstrand and 11 kilometres from Cape Town, which probably measure from different points.
On the start of detention: the entry speaks of the late 17th century and then names Autshumato in the mid-17th century. On the political prison: 1959 in the UNESCO description, 1961 in the entry. On Mandela: more than 20 years in the UNESCO description, 18 in the entry. On closure: 1991 for political prisoners, 1996 for the rest.
What the sources do not say
The texts consulted give no opening hours, prices or visiting rules beyond the data in the entry, and refer to the official website of the Robben Island Museum. UNESCO does not give the year of inscription, which another source gives as 1999.
It was not possible to find in the sources the number of visitors or the surface area in the UNESCO description.
Numbers to remember
The island measures about 5 square kilometres, is 3.3 kilometres long and 1.9 wide. It has more than 700 buildings and sites, a buffer zone of one nautical mile and 116 residents in 2011.
The dates are 1488 for Dias, 1654 for the settlers, 1845 for the leper colony, 1865 for the lighthouse, 1961 for the political prison, 1991 and 1996 for the closures and 1999 for the inscription.
How to read Robben Island
Robben Island reads as a place of isolation, used by different regimes to keep out of sight those they did not wish to see. UNESCO says so with a list: prison, hospital, military base.
Criterion (vi) takes the further step: the same walls became a symbol of freedom and democracy, and the value of the property also lies in this reversal.
An island that changes use
The island’s history is a succession of functions: supply station, grazing, prison, whaling, leper colony, military base and prison again. Each left traces, and UNESCO uses them as proof of authenticity.
For readers of the sources, the useful point is that none of the phases erases the others. The island is not only Mandela’s prison, even though that is its best-known image.
The weight of memory
The entry notes that many guides are former prisoners and that for many Black South Africans the island is a symbol of oppression. This is a point that UNESCO does not report, but it helps in understanding criterion (vi).
The memory of the island is not a closed matter. The visit becomes a way of listening to direct witnesses, and this will change over time, because former prisoners are becoming fewer. The sources consulted do not address the subject, and the guide limits itself to flagging it as an open question for those who organise the visit and the preservation of the accounts.
Future environmental risks
The entry reports that the 2022 IPCC report lists the island among African cultural sites threatened by flooding and coastal erosion, in a high-emissions scenario that is now considered less likely.
For an island that lies only a few metres above the sea, the risk is real. UNESCO does not mention climate change, and the guide adds no forecasts.
Why the sources are read together
UNESCO is the source for criteria, integrity, authenticity and management. The encyclopaedia entry is the source for the detailed chronology, the names of the prisoners, the visit and the wildlife.
Where the two sources diverge, as on the date the political prison opened, the guide reports both without choosing, because the UNESCO sections in other languages do not match one another.
A note on the sources
For Robben Island, UNESCO is available in several languages and the sections do not always say the same thing, for example on Mandela and on the opening of the prison. This guide flags every difference and does not smooth it over.
The history in stages
In 1488 Dias, in 1654 the settlers, from the late 17th century detention, in 1845 the leper colony, in 1961 the political prison, in 1991 the end of political detention, in 1996 the national monument and in 1999 the inscription.
Other dates appear in the sources, for example 1806 for the whaling station and 1819 for Makanda Nxele, but they do not change the overall picture.
Key dates
- 1488Bartolomeu Dias sights the island
- 1845Leper colony
- 1961Political prison
- 1996National monument
- 1999Inscription on the UNESCO List (according to the sources)